Why I Write Mystery Letters

By Sara Rossett

How long has it been since you’ve received a letter or a card in the mail?

Do you get more junk mail than anything else?

How nice would it be to find something in your mailbox that you want to read!

And if the letter included a mystery to solve—even better!

That’s the reason I decided to write a story told in installments and mailed through the post to readers.

How it began: Kickstarter

When I ran a Kickstarter campaign in 2022 for a special edition hardcover of my first Olive Belgrave novel, Murder at Archly Manor, I offered a mystery, The Purloined Peacock, as another story told in letters from Olive. Readers loved it.

And I enjoyed writing them! Writing short and telling a story in installments was a new challenge. Instead of telling a story in seventy thousand words, I had about ten thousand words, which meant writing tighter and boiling down the story to its essential elements while still retaining the zippy lighthearted tone of the 1920s series.

The other unique aspect of the letters is that I’m able to include artwork. My latest versions of the letters are in full color (as opposed to the first round, which were black and white). I’ve commissioned custom illustrations for some of the letters and enjoy working with my designer to create unique looks for each set of letters.

With each round of letters, I refine the process of creating them and try to make them more enjoyable for readers. As I mentioned, I’ve added color and custom illustrations. With my most recent letter set, I added international delivery.

Many letter subscriptions run year-round on a recurring monthly subscription plan, but I decided I didn’t want to do that. My letters are one-time-purchas, limited subscriptions.

In 2026, I launched a limited year-long subscription that went out twice a month, but I decided I like the shorter letter sets of 8 or 12 letters, which are more manageable for me and leave me plenty of time to write my novels. The readers enjoy the letters, but still want novels, so I need a schedule that allows me to do both.

Readers like opening their mailbox and finding a new installment. The physical component is a draw, but it also brings challenges. Sometimes letters go astray and I have to replace them, or a reader moves and I need to update their address. I’m new to handling physical products, so these are aspects of customer service that I haven’t had to deal with before.

Starting Mysteries in the Mail has been a learning process, but I’m so glad I did it. It gives me variety in my creative life and also lets my readers have more stories in the 1920s High Society Lady Detective series.

If you’re interested in physical products for your readers, I suggest you start small and iterate as you go. So much of our world is digital and readers love something they can hold.

#

The Purloined Peacock letters are available to preorder now in full-color on custom-illustrated letterhead at https://www.curios.com/c/WNX675.

Letters will be mailed once a week for eight weeks. The preorder closes December 14, 2026. The first mailing date is December 21, with an estimated delivery of the week of January 4th.

#

.

USA Today bestselling author Sara Rosett writes lighthearted mysteries for readers who enjoy atmospheric settings and puzzling whodunits. 

She is the author of the High Society Lady Detective historical mysteries, a 1920s historical mystery series, as well as three contemporary cozy series: the Murder on Location series, the On the Run series, and the Ellie Avery series.

Sara’s nonfiction for authors includes How to Outline a Cozy Mystery Workbook, How to Write a Series, and Trope Thesaurus: Mystery and Thriller. When she’s not writing the next book, you can find Sara reading Golden Age mysteries, watching Korean dramas, or bargain shopping.

.

.

.

Unknown's avatar

Author: Jackie Houchin

First, I am a believer in Jesus Christ, so my views and opinions are filtered through what God's Word says and I believe. I'm a wife, a mom, a grandma and now a great grandma. I write articles and reviews, and I dabble in short fiction. I enjoy living near the ocean, doing gardening (for beauty and food) and traveling - in other countries, if possible. My heart is for Christian missions, and I'm compiling a collections of Missionary Kids' stories to publish. (I also like kittens and cats and reading mysteries.)

6 thoughts on “Why I Write Mystery Letters”

  1. Sara, Your short letter mysteries might also be a way to get readers interested in reading longer books. I found that doing a book of short stories also got people to read. They can manage a twenty to fifty page short story in one sitting. Then, if they like a good mystery, they just might go one to the longer ones, but at least they are reading. We need to get kids and adults to start reading more…and maybe even see if they might want to write their own stories. Read On!

    Liked by 1 person

  2. What a clever and creative way to share your stories with readers. Now that most people no longer use “snail mail” for letters and cards, we rarely look forward to looking in our mailboxes. You’ve come up with a way to use an old-fashioned system to do something fresh and modern. Bravo!

    Liked by 1 person

  3. I receive Mysteries by Mail from several authors, and I have to admit, I like Sara Rossett’s the best. The story is interesting (just complicated enough), the characters are fun, the illustrations are colorful, and the envelope isn’t filled with extra stuff you need to read and process. (I’ve subscribed to some of those kinds, and it gets to be TOO MUCH to read all the extras. (For ME at least.) I’ve already renewed for the next set by Sara.

    Another “mystery by mail” I like comes as a single typed letter. It’s suspenseful, sometimes heart-stopping. It’s “The Long War, Correspondence, from Occupied France.” I would recommend this one and the one that Sara Rossett writes. (Unless you like sorting through a lot of stuff.)

    Thank You, Sara for being our Guest Writer this month! I’m hooked.

    Like

  4. Such a great idea. We really need to keep letter writing alive! Think of those who don’t use computers and communicate with the world via the mail. Denmark was talking of abolishing their mail delivery system, due to low numbers! We can never let that happen here! And installments are a wonderful idea – always something to look forward to. And less time-consuming to write!

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply